By David Lazarus
That ka-ching sound you hear isn't just AT&T Wireless
receiving a $41 billion buyout offer from rival Cingular.
It's also Ed Whitacre, chief exec of SBC, notching up another
performance milestone for his annual pay package.
SBC is the majority owner of Cingular -- it'll put up nearly
two-thirds of the cash for AT&T Wireless -- and is thus
the ultimate beneficiary of what will be, assuming the deal
goes through, the nation's largest wireless network.
Why will this swell Whitacre's pockets? Well, if he can
score millions in bonus money for losing business, imagine
how much he'll make for actually expanding SBC's reach.
In a regulatory filing on Friday, as most people were focusing
on the three-day holiday weekend, SBC revealed that Whitacre's
2003 compensation was more than double what he made in the
previous year.
Whitacre received a base salary of $2.1 million, a bonus
of $5.7 million, $2.4 million from the company's long-term
incentive program, $7.2 million in restricted stock awards
and $2.1 million in additional compensation.
That's a grand total of $19.5 million (not including stock
options), compared with $8.6 million in 2002. Whitacre's
base salary was unchanged, so the increase comes exclusively
in bonus money, returning him to near the $21 million level
he enjoyed in 2001.
By comparison, BellSouth CEO Duane Ackerman earned $2.3
million in 2002 salary and bonuses, while Ivan Seidenberg,
CEO of Verizon Communications, pulled down $9.5 million
that same year. Their 2003 compensation has yet to be revealed.
But what makes Whitacre's whopping pay increase so noteworthy
is that SBC, by virtually any yardstick, performed dismally
last year.
|
The company's stock was among
the five worst performers in the Dow Jones industrial average,
shedding nearly 4 percent of its value for all of 2003 (while
the Dow itself posted a 25 percent gain).
SBC's revenues have dropped for 13 straight quarters. Net
income, adjusted for accounting changes, also has headed
south in recent years.
According to SBC's proxy statement filed last week, the
company has underperformed comparable telecom firms and
the S&P 500 since 2001.
Nevertheless, Anne Vincent, an SBC spokeswoman, said Whitacre
deserved to have his pay more than doubled because he met
financial goals set by the board of directors (for which
he serves as chairman).
Those goals, Vincent said, are tied to advances made in
selling new services like long-distance and high-speed Internet
access. They're also tied to customer satisfaction, which
SBC says is up, according to the company's own surveys.
"From an operational standpoint," Vincent said,
"SBC had a very good year in 2003. Mr. Whitacre's compensation
reflects that."
So now we have Cingular on the verge of acquiring AT&T
Wireless, which almost certainly will be seen by SBC's board
as an operational triumph. Vincent, however, couldn't say
what impact the deal will have on Whitacre's pay this year.
"That's for the board to decide," she said. "They'll
evaluate each executive's performance against various goals."
Anyone want to take bets that Whitacre won't be disappointed
when bonus time rolls around next year?
This is an excerpt From Lazarus at Large by David
Lazarus', his column appears Wednesdays, Fridays and Sundays.
He also can be seen regularly on KTVU's "Mornings on
2." Send tips or feedback to dlazarus@sfchronicle.com.
©2004 San Francisco Chronicle
|